Flexible Assessment

Overview

Flexible assessments offer students choice in how they navigate time, modality and engagement when completing course assessments. When thoughtfully designed and implemented, flexible assessments support students in demonstrating (both to the instructor and themselves) what they have learned without defaulting to traditional assessment practices that do not reflect students’ wholeness or priorities.

"For large assignments like term papers, it's helpful to have a few ‘check in’ due dates where I need to provide an outline/annotated bibliography/etc., this helps me keep on track and organize my ideas to a specific timeline but isn't as demanding or overwhelming as weekly assignments."

- PhD Student, Science and Social Science, Western University

Meanwhile, offering multiple assessment pathways (or “choose your own adventure”-style learning) offers students the opportunity to select among multiple pathways to meet course learning outcomes and demonstrate their learning. This approach focuses on providing choice among learning activities and assessments.

Rationale

Flexible assessment practices can benefit both students and instructors. They create more equitable and engaging opportunities for students to demonstrate their learning, while giving instructors a fuller picture of what students know and can do. When flexibility is intentionally built into assessment design, it can also reduce the need to respond to access needs through individual exceptions or last-minute adjustments. 

 

"Having flexible deadlines for assessments and accommodating different ways of completing assignments while still meeting the requirements of the learning [and makes it easier for me to manage and succeed in my courses].”

- Undergraduate Student, Arts and Humanities, Western University

To support student accessibility, motivation, and engagement, it is important to be transparent with students about the pedagogical and equity reasons that have shaped your flexible assessment design. Further, because students may be unfamiliar with or anxious about non-traditional assessments or approaches to deadlines, it may be helpful to introduce additional scaffolding and support opportunities, including in-class practice or collaborations with relevant support units on campus (e.g., Writing Support Centre; Western Libraries). 

"I love it when professors give many (say, 10) questions for, say, Part A of an exam and then say, ‘pick 5.’ It gives me the opportunity to pick a question that relates to a concept that I found interesting in class. Similarly, I also like essay assignments that have multiple topics to choose from for the same reason.”

- Undergraduate Student, Arts and Humanities, Western University

Meanwhile, offering students choice in assessment types or scheduling (i.e., multiple pathways) increases engagement and encourages autonomy. It allows them to take responsibility for their learning and deepen their understanding via learning activities that are meaningful for them. It can also welcome and encourage multiple ways of knowing, being, and communicating in relationship to the subject matter and themes of the learning community, and in ways that reflect the many values, goals, cultures, and languages students carry with them. 

Ultimately, flexible assessment practices can: 

  • support multiple ways of knowing, being, and communicating in a learning environment
  • enhance student engagement 
  • avoid assumptions about student accessibility needs
  • recognize that students are whole persons with complex lives 
  • support creative experimentation and play within a course
  • demonstrate trust that students will make decisions that are right for them 
  • model student autonomy through choice-making

Policy/Legislation/Framework References  

Guidance

Flexible Assessments

Flexibility in assessment can take many forms, including flexibility in time, modality, and engagement types:

Time Flexibility

  • Flexible deadlines (slip days / grace days; built in; “late days bank”)
    • e.g., building student autonomy through built-in flexible deadline dates for all students – 24 – 48 hours after the due date; or individualized flexibility – late days bank / slip days / grace days – that students can draw on across multiple assignments 

Modality Flexibility

  • Choice of assessment topic
    • e.g., select from a proposed list of topics; student-created topics
  • Choice of format (assessment genre)
    • e.g., research essay, podcast, presentation, public-facing writing, policy brief, community partnerships, research poster
  • Choice of modality (assessment communication mode(s))
    • e.g., written, oral, performance-based
  • Co-created assessment
    • e.g., develop the shell of an assessment and then invite students to collaboratively refine it; co-create an assessment from nothing; collaborate on determining a rubric or criteria for success

Engagement Flexibility

  • Choice of assessment pathways
    • e.g., engaging with community partners or completing assessments within the classroom community
  • Choice in group or individual work (to minimize unwanted disclosure of disability or neurodivergence to other students for the purposes of accommodation)
    • e.g., invite students to share their preference: individual work, self-selected group, instructor-selected group
  • Option to drop lowest assessment(s)
    • e.g., drop lowest two grades; complete a certain number of assessments

An icon with a check mark.Try

  • Considering the course context when determining where / when flexibility is appropriate
  • Being transparent with your students about where / why / how you have incorporated flexibility
  • Remaining mindful of impact on your workload in terms of developing and offering feedback on the assessment and how you will scaffold the assessment for students for whom this approach is new
  • Identifying whether the assessment type/design will require approximately the same amount of work or considerably more work than a traditional assessment (for the instructor and the students)

An icon with an X mark.Avoid

  • Being too ambitious – you can start small if that is more helpful for you and your students
  • Assuming that your students will understand the new/flexible approaches to assessment

Multiple Pathways

There are many ways that multiple assessment pathways can be created in a course. Choice may be offered about number of assessments, timing of assessments, modality of assessments, weighting of assessments, and so on. It is important to provide clear information about the choices available to students and, depending on the kinds of choices offered, it may be necessary to document and track student selections.

Some examples of multiple assessment pathways include:

  • A choice between a short international learning opportunity and engagement in alternate local activities, each with its own associated activities and assessments.
  • A choice among a range of different kinds of assessments (presentations, quizzes, podcasts, written reflections, or other formats), each with an associated points value, where students choose their preferred combination that adds up to a required number of points.
  • A choice of three from among five possible short writing assignments, allowing students to select the timing and topics that work best for them.
  • A choice among tests which together will amount to a set percentage of the course grade, where students can write more tests at a lower weight or fewer at a higher weight -- for instance, two midterm tests at 15% each or just one of the two at 30% -- along with a required cumulative final exam worth 45%.

In her blog post on Choose your own adventure learning, Bonnie Stachowiak provides examples of the kinds of choices she provided in an undergraduate Business course and the “contract” she used to record student selections. In a follow-up post, she adds reflections on what she would change as she further develops this approach.

An icon with a check mark.Try

  • Providing clear information on the elements that are subject to student choice
  • Ensuring there is a way to document student choices for their own record and the instructor’s tracking
  • Encouraging students to do some assessments early in the semester so that work does not pile up
  • Being aware that if students are completing different combinations of assessments, possibly at different weights, this may be a challenge for the gradebook features of the Learning Management System

An icon with an X mark.Avoid

  • Proliferating so many choices that they become unmanageable for the instructor and overwhelming for the student

Resources

Centre for Teaching and Learning, Flexible Approaches for Setting Deadlines. University of Alberta. 

Centre for Teaching and Learning. Academic Consideration Policy. Western University. 

CIEL Blog. Flexible Assessment. Vancouver Island University. 

Hills, M., & Peacock, K. (2022). Replacing power with flexible structure: Implementing flexible deadlines to improve student learning experiences. Teaching and Learning Inquiry, 10. 

Society for Teaching and Learning in Higher Education (STLHE). (2022). Use Flexible Assessment to Engage and Motivate Learners. 

Stachowiak, B. (2015). Choose your own adventure learning. Teaching in Higher Education. 

---. (2015). Choose your own adventure learning (part 2). Teaching in Higher Education.